Paul Hartley is pictured during Celtic's 1:1 draw with Manchester United
in the Champions League.
Group E
.
VILLARREAL 1:0 CELTIC (0:0) (30.09.08, Villarreal)
Artur Boruc, Mark Wilson, Gary Caldwell, Stephen McManus (c), Lee Naylor, Shunsuke Nakamura (Barry Robson 74),
Scott Brown, Paul Hartley (Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink 82), Aiden McGeady,
Shaun Maloney (Scott McDonald 72), Georgios Samaras
.
MANCHESTER UTD 3:0 CELTIC (1:0) (21.10.08, Manchester)
Artur Boruc, Mark Wilson, Gary Caldwell, Stephen McManus (c), Glenn Loovens, Lee Naylor,
Shunsuke Nakamura (Paul Hartley 62), Scott Brown, Barry Robson (Shaun Maloney 62), Aiden McGeady,
Scott McDonald (Cillian Sheridan 77)
.
CELTIC 1:1 MANCHESTER UTD (1:0) McDonald (13). (05.11.08, Glasgow)
Artur Boruc, Andreas Hinkel, Gary Caldwell, Stephen McManus (c), Mark Wilson, Barry Robson, Scott Brown,
Paul Hartley, Shaun Maloney (Darren O'Dea 76), Cillian Sheridan (Massimon Donati 64),
Scott McDonald (Ben Hutchinson 82)
.
CELTIC 2:0 VILLARREAL (2:0) Maloney (14), McGeady (45+2). (10.12.08, Glasgow)
Artur Boruc, Andreas Hinkel, Gary Caldwell, Stephen McManus (c), Mark Wilson (Darren O'Dea 82),
Shunsuke Nakamura, Scott Brown, Paul Hartley, Shaun Maloney, Aiden McGeady (Paul McGowan 76),
Georgios Samaras (Scott McDonald 82)